Post fire claim advice: After the fire comes the adjuster

Washington Post

In July, when fire tore through the Northwest mansion belonging to local
activist and arts patron Peggy Cooper Cafritz, it set off what is
likely to be a long journey toward rebuilding. Facing total loss,
Cafritz hired a public insurance adjuster to estimate the dollar amount
and help prepare her homeowners insurance claim.
“It would be a truly daunting experience to do something like this on
your own, for this level of claim,” said her nephew Casey Cooper, who is
a Washington lawyer.
Though the adjuster, Harvey Goodman, president of Goodman-Gable-Gould
Adjusters International in Rockville, would not comment specifically on
Cafritz’s claim, he said another total-loss claim he processed earlier
this year took about five months to settle with the insurance company.
Many people don’t realize the emotional toll such a loss may take on
them, Goodman said, and it can be difficult to recognize all the aspects
of such a complex claim.
“People get traumatized and emotional, as they should, when their houses
burn down,” he said. “You’ve got to look at this as a business
transaction, because that’s how the insurance company is going to look
at it.”
Despite the trauma, there are steps homeowners can take when dealing
with their insurance company that can minimize the chances of running
into trouble with their claim.
One of the most frequent complaints against insurers arises when an
insurer bases its rebuilding cost estimate on rates charged by its own
contractors and a homeowner has the work done by a different contractor
who charges more, said Thomas E. Hampton, commissioner of the District’s
Department of Insurance, Securities and Banking. That office fielded 64
complaints against homeowners insurance companies last year. The
majority of the roughly 1,000 complaints the office received last year
concerned auto policies.) But Hampton said he thinks there are many more
complaints that go unreported.
Several lawyers and insurance experts offered advice on ways homeowners
can be more savvy when dealing with insurance companies:
— Never agree to a recorded interview with someone else’s insurance
company, says Paulette Chapman, a personal-injury lawyer in the
District. You might be asked for such an interview if someone fell on
your steps and filed an insurance claim with their own company, for
example. They might ask leading questions that can be used against you,
she said.
Offer to submit a written statement instead, says Alice Wolfson,
chairman of the board for United Policyholders, a consumer group based
in San Francisco. You also can request that your own lawyer be present
when you speak to the insurance company.
“Most insurance policy holders want to be the most honest, forthright
insurance policy holder in the world,” she said. “They’re going to give
tons and tons of information that could possibly be used against them.”
— Understand that the word “flood” rings alarm bells with insurance
adjusters. Most homeowners’ policies do not cover floods, so you should
check your policy for the insurance company’s definition of flooding,
says Amy Danise, editor of the Web site. Typically, she said,
water coming from outside the home won’t be covered, but water that
originated inside the home, say from a broken pipe, probably will be.
Calling your incident a flood in the initial claim could delay your
— Keep good records. Danise suggests keeping a log of all
correspondence with the insurance company at every step of the way,
noting with whom you spoke, date and time, and what the person told you
about your claim or the value of the damage. Notes will come in handy if
there’s a dispute or a legal complaint. Experts also suggest taking
photos of the damage and writing down everything you remember about the
incident immediately after it happens.
— Ask your insurance agent to stay on the phone with you during the
interview with the claims department, suggests Mel Pine, an Allstate
agent in Purcellville, Va. Pine says he does this to help the client
feel more comfortable and to translate industry jargon.
— Get a copy of police or fire department records before filing a theft
or fire claim, Wolfson says. They help document that the incident
actually happened and that you did not purposely cause it.
— Don’t rush into decisions. Though a claim should be handled
efficiently and in a reasonable amount of time, Robert Hunter, director
of insurance for the Consumer Federation of America, recommends caution
when decisions seem to be made too fast. “You want to make sure you’re
getting everything you’re entitled to,” he said. In particular, he urges
caution in signing any final releases, which indicate the end of a
claim. For example, if a fire damages the walls in a home, don’t accept a
small reimbursement for the cosmetic damage before you know whether
there is structural damage to the walls, Hunter said.
— If your claim is denied, find out exactly what language in the policy
the company uses in its reasoning, Hunter said. “It stops them from
coming up with new reasons for denying your claim,” he said. The same
goes for their estimates of what your property and damage are worth.
“You have to understand where their numbers come from. You have the
right to ask,” he said. “It’s your claim.”
— Consider hiring a lawyer or public adjuster if a dispute persists,
Hunter said. He suggested consulting rankings, such as those done by, for your specific insurance company before deciding
whether to hire a public adjuster.
— Prepare for insurance claims before they even happen. Planning and
keeping good documentation will go a long way toward preventing problems
with claims, says Carolyn Gorman, a vice president of the Insurance
Information Institute, an industry group. Make a home inventory, some
insurance companies will help you with this) and take photographs of
your belongings. Keep sales receipts for big-ticket items. And store
your inventory records online or at someone else’s house so they will be
accessible if your home is

The information presented in this publication is for general informational purposes and is not a substitute for legal advice. If you have a specific legal issue or problem, United Policyholders recommends that you consult with an attorney. Guidance on hiring professional help can be found in the “Find Help” section of United Policyholders does not sell insurance or certify, endorse or warrant any of the insurance products, vendors, or professionals identified on our website.

Date: July 17, 2024