Water Leak Teresa Paul asked 2 months ago
Water Leak

We recently noticed damage to our pine floor after moving a file cabinet in our living room. The damage extended under the flooring toward our kitchen. I then began noticing that the Stainmaster vinyl plank flooring in the kitchen was buckling, with water seeping through.

I submitted a claim to our insurance company on August 14, 2026, and asked what we should do. They advised us to call a plumber. The first plumber came out and found no damage under the sink or to our cabinets. He also inspected the crawl space and advised us that he did not see a leak. The insurance adjuster then came to our home, took pictures, and briefly entered the crawl space. She concluded that the water was caused by condensation and runoff from our neighbor’s yard, which she considered to be flood-like conditions. She advised us that the damage was the result of seepage, wear, and tear. The insurance company closed our claim on August 20, 2026. I called the insurance company again, went through the appropriate channels, and asked to speak with the adjuster’s supervisor. By this point, the floor was sagging and the damage was expanding beyond the center of the kitchen floor. The supervisor advised us to call another plumber. We contacted a second plumber. He entered the crawl space and cut through the vapor barrier and insulation. He discovered that the damaged pipe was hidden between the floor joists, underneath the flooring but above the insulation and vapor barrier. He advised us that there was a burst supply line and that the first plumber had not cut far enough into the insulation to locate the leak. The second plumber replaced the damaged supply line on September 4, 2026. As a result, the water damage continued from the date we first reported the claim, August 14, 2026, until the leak was finally located and repaired on September 4, 2026. Despite this new information confirming that the source of the water was a burst supply line, the insurance company will not reopen the claim and has refused to send another adjuster to inspect the additional damage. We were forced to hire and pay a restoration company ourselves to dry out our home. The drying and demolition work took place from September 5, 2026, through October 3, 2026. We have already incurred approximately $7,000 in expenses for drying and removing the damaged materials. This amount does not include the plumbers’ bills or the cost of rebuilding and repairing our home. Given that the actual source of the water damage was later confirmed to be a burst supply line, what can we do now to have the insurance company reconsider or reopen our claim?

1 Answers
Alexis 'Lexi' Ricci Alexis \'Lexi\' Ricci Staff answered 1 month ago

Hi Teresa,

Based on what you’ve described, the second plumber’s finding of a burst supply line is important new evidence that appears to contradict the insurer’s original conclusion about the cause of the water damage.

We recommend sending the insurer a written request to reopen and reconsider the claim. Include the second plumber’s report, photos, restoration invoices, and a timeline showing that you promptly reported the damage, followed the insurer’s instructions, and repaired the pipe once the actual source was located.

Ask the insurer to reinspect the property and provide a new written coverage determination based on the confirmed plumbing failure. If they continue to deny the claim, ask them to identify the specific policy language and facts supporting the denial.

You may also find these UP resources helpful:

If the insurer will not reconsider the claim after receiving the new evidence, you may also consider filing a complaint with the Kentucky Department of Insurance.

Best of luck,

Team UP