Cleaning service reserve on personal property Aaron Vandyke asked 3 weeks ago
Cleaning service reserve on personal property

My mother-in-law had a fire. It started in an adjoining condo unit and affected two rooms in her unit, with smoke damage throughout.

Her Coverage C limit is just over $50,000. The restoration company has estimated a reserve of $25,000–$30,000 for the inventory, pack-out, cleaning, and storage of salvageable items.

Nearly 60% of her Coverage C limit seems high, but when I raise this concern, they simply state that it is a reserve and that they will provide an itemized breakdown later.

They also say they can only determine whether something can be cleaned, not whether it should be cleaned—for example, when the cost of cleaning exceeds the cost of replacement.

I am trying to help her navigate this process.

Does the company have to provide an inventory list before removing everything? Can we dispute specific items or cleaning decisions? What rights do we have to control what is cleaned and keep costs down to ensure sufficient coverage remains for replacing damaged belongings?

1 Answers
Josh Engle Josh Engle Expert answered 1 week ago

Hi Aaron,

If you hired the restoration company, they work for you, not the insurance company. I wouldn’t let them remove any contents until they provide a written estimate covering pack-out, storage, itemized cleaning costs, and pack-back. They should be able to put together an itemized quote fairly quickly so you can make an informed decision about which items are worth cleaning.

Submit the estimate to the insurance company, with payment made to you. Note that if you sign a “direction to pay” or similar document, the insurance company may pay the restoration company directly, leaving you with less control over the process. I’d recommend not signing one.

Restoration companies also often produce a “total loss” photo inventory of items that can’t be cleaned or aren’t cost-effective to clean. Ask for a copy, as it will help support the claim for items that can’t be saved.

Finally, because the fire started in the adjoining unit, the neighbor’s liability coverage may be another source of recovery if her contents limit runs short. That would generally depend on the neighbor being at fault, so ask her adjuster whether they plan to pursue the neighbor’s insurer and how any recovery would be shared with her.

Best, Josh