Erie Insurance Exchange vs. Hollock
Year 2003
Court Pennsylvania Superior Court
Case Number 67 MAP 2005 (Supreme Court), 298 MDA 2002 (Superior Court)
Issue
  • Bad Faith
State
  • Pennsylvania

In Pennsylvania a violation of the Unfair Practices Act should be relevant evidence of bad faith. An insurance company’s violations of its own internal guidelines, manuals and procedures is relevant evidence of bad faith. Case upholds post –Campbell ratio of compensatory to punitive damages of 10:1.

Related Docs
Author UP's briefs were written pro bono by John N. Ellison, Timothy P. Law of Anderson Kill & Olick, PC
Related Cases
Moody v. Oregon Community Credit Union and Federal Insurance Company
Year: 2022
Court: Oregon Supreme Court
Case Number: S069409
Issue:
  • Bad Faith
State:
  • Oregon

In its amicus curiae brief, United Policyholders addresses the question of whether a policyholder can recover extra-contractual damages by bringing negligence per se cause of action for mishandling of an insurance claim in a way that violates Oregon statute. United Policyholders’ brief argues that insurance consumer…
Peterson v. Western National Mutual Insurance
Year: 2019
Court: Supreme Court of Minnesota
Case Number: A18-1081
Issue:
  • Bad Faith
State:
  • Minnesota

In its brief, UP weighed in on Minnesota’s bad faith statute, § 604.18, in order to protect Minnesota policyholders when an insurance company does not complete a reasonable investigation of a claim. UP weighed in to avoid a narrow reading of the statute which would not…
Ballard vs. Farmers Insurance Group
Year: 2001
Court: Texas Court of Appeals
Case Number:
Issue:
  • Bad Faith
State:
  • Texas

Insurance nullification by litigation; bad faith
Baugh Construction Company vs. Granite State Insurance Company
Year: 1996
Court: California Court of Appeal, 3rd District
Case Number: C023071
Issue:
  • Bad Faith
State:
  • California

Under New Jersey law, the obligation of good faith and fair dealing extends to the assertion, settlement and litigation of contract claims