Our policy has the following provision: “Our Option. We may repair or replace any part of the property damaged or stolen with similar property. Any property we pay for or replace becomes our property.” Does this mean that all items the insurance company pays ACV or Replacement Cost for become the property of the insurance company? Or do the damaged items remain our property to do with as we like? Our home was smoke/debris-impacted, not a total loss. If there are items we don’t intend to clean or replace, but want to keep in their damaged state, do we have a right to do that even if we are paid the ACV? Do we have the right to keep damaged items for which we are paid the replacement cost?
Hi Crissy,
You should be able to work with your insurer to keep items that have sentimental or personal value, even if they’ve been damaged by smoke or debris. However, your policy does give the insurer certain salvage rights, so it’s important to clarify whether they intend to exercise those rights before settling your claim.
We suggest asking your adjuster, in writing, whether you can retain the items you want to keep and whether doing so would affect your payment. If the insurer proposes a deduction for salvage value, ask them to explain how they calculated it.
For additional guidance, see UP’s FAQs About Property Damage Insurance Claims and 10 Tips for Settling a Contents Claim.
Best, Lexi